“The most illogical argument in Common Sense“
Thomas Paine, an American revolutionist, and writer of Common Sense. Paine gave his all in this essay, using fiery rhetoric and intense language, one might have their already lighten spark expand into flames. However intense this essay may be, it can not distract from the lack of consistency and logic dissipating that might not have existed from the beginning. This work of writing is based on rhetoric. Thomas Paine’s rhetoric is his strongest ally. Dramatically altering events to seem more perverse than in actuality, riling up the colonists to persuade them of revolution. Paine deeply desired revolution and believed it was the only way to freedom.
In his account, Paine stated that the colonists desired revolution as a form of rebellion and an act towards freedom. Paine had interviewed maybe a few hundred people and based the entire colony’s feelings on their perspective. He made it seem like all colonists were anxious to start the revolution when the reality was, many were undecided.
Revolution needed to have war. Freedom was desperate for rebellion. America needed to declare independence. If this were true, Canada would not have the freedoms that it does. While they never completely severed the ties to Britain, they still were allowed the same freedoms Americans enjoyed. The United States essentially paid seven years, lives, and money to no longer have to declare Britain as their country.
Paine believed that commerce would weaken the nation. His argument was if we keep trading with England and gaining wealth, there would not be as much motivation to begin a revolution. If we become richer, we would have less reason to fight. This logic does not add up. If you gain more wealth, you are more likely to want to protect said wealth. If you have more money, you are more capable to protect your wealth. At this moment in history, Britain was the most powerful country. Britain’s expertise was commerce, and their wealth was unimaginable. Britain invested their wealth into a military and the economy, allowing both to continue to grow.
This essay was impactful, and I understand why. With many young men eager to fight for their rights, these fallacies and contradictions would have flown over their heads. But we can not ignore that many of Thomas Paine’s ideas were wrong, deceitful, and sometimes idiotic.